Is American Judaism Going Down the Toilet?: Reflections on the Recent Pew Study of the American Jewish Community
The Pew Research Center is a highly respected institute that conducts many serious studies about the nature of religion in contemporary American life. Last month they issued a 200 page report entited “A Portrait of Jewish Americans.” It is the first such comprehensive study of the state of the American Jewish community to be released since the last National Jewish Population Survey, back in 2001. For this study, 70,000 screening interviews were conducted, covering all 50 states in their search to identify Jewish respondents. Of that group, they conducted fuller interviews with almost 3,500 Jews.
The results of this survey have generated a tremendous amount of conversation within the American Jewish community. One writer claims that as his of his writing, over a million words have been published evaluating those results. I suspect that his estimate is low.
While it is impossible for me to give you all the results of the Pew Study in one posting, let me hit upon some of its highlights, both the good news and the bad news:
- 94% of those Jews surveyed claimed that they are proud to be Jewish. That, of course, is very good news.
- The percentage of adult Americans who say that they are Jewish is a little less than 2%, which is about half of what it was in the late 1950’s. Unfortunately, the American Jewish community is shrinking.
- 22% of those interviewed claim that they have no religious identity. It should be noted that this statistic is very much in line with another statistic from a Pew survey of religious identity in general in America, where 20% of Americans claimed to have no religious identity. Yet it should be of little comfort to us that we Jews are like the rest of our fellow Americans, moving further and further away from our religious roots.
- Among those Jews who claim no religious identity, it should be noted that they are far more represented among younger adults than older adults. If you break it down by generation you find that among the Greatest Generation – those born between 1914 & 1927 – only 7% claim no religion. Among the Silent Generation – those born between 1928 & 1945 – the number goes up to 14%. Among Baby Boomers – those born between 1946 & 1964 – the number is 19%. For Gen X’er – born between 1965 & 1980 – the number is 26%. And finally, among the Millennials – those born after 1980 – the number is 32%, almost 5 times greater than the Greatest Generation and almost twice as great than Baby Boomers. To say the least, this trend is frightening and should be of profound concern to us Jews who wish to see our faith survive long into the future.
- When asked if being Jewish was more about culture and ancestry than about religion, 62% of the respondents said that their Jewish identity was exclusively about culture and ancestry; 15% said it was about religion; and 23% said it was a combination of all three. Such statistics do not bode well for those of us who work for the continued existence of synagogues like our own.
- The rate of intermarriage is also up. 60% of those who married since the year 2000 are intermarried, as compared to 40% of those who married in the ‘80’s and 17% of those who married in the ‘70’s. Considering the fact that only 20% of intermarried couples raise their children as Jewish, this poses yet another challenge for the future.
- Regarding denominational identification, Reform Judaism is the largest denomination among American Jews, with 35% identifying as Reform. The next largest group, with 30%, are those who claim no denominational identification. 18% claim to be Conservative, 10% claim to be Orthodox, and 6% claim to be other, such as Reconstructionist or Jewish Renewal. However, it should be noted that the Orthodox, though small, have many more young people and generally raise larger families. So we can expect to see this percentage grow for the Orthodox in the future.
- Passover remains the most practiced Jewish observance with 70% claiming they participate in a Passover Seder. However, that is down from the 78% which was reported in the National Jewish Population Survey.
- 69% of those surveyed stated that they feel an attachment to the State of Israel. This statistic remains unchanged from the National Jewish Population Survey. We would have hoped to see this number rise as a result of programs like Birthright. At least we are holding our own.
- When asked, “What Does It Mean to Be Jewish?” 73% said remembering the Holocaust; 69% said leading an ethical and moral life; 56% said working for justice and equality; 49% said being intellectually curious; 43% said caring about Israel; 42% said having a good sense of humor; 28% said being a part of a Jewish community; 19% said observing Jewish law; and 14% said eating traditional Jewish foods. It is deeply disturbing that so many more Jews view having a sense of humor as more essential to their Jewish identity than either practicing our faith or being part of a Jewish community.
These statistics but scratch the surface of this study. Yet, as a synagogue, they should give us much to ponder. Reactions to this study have run the gamut from anxious hand wringing to almost joyous jubilation, depending upon one’s perception of American Jewish life in the first place.
One writer applauds the grim aspects of this report. He claims that the reason most cultural Jews keep any Jewish traditions or identity is because they feel guilty on account of their parents. He then goes on to announce that it is time for Jews to get over their guilt and drop these meaningless observances. While another author recalls how one edition of Look Magazine, back in 1964, had as its cover story “The Vanishing American Jew” and predicted that by the 21st century there would no longer be any Jews left in the United States. He then joyfully quotes Mark Twain who said, “The reports of my death are greatly exaggerated.”
There are those who look at the report and offer sage advice. A rabbi who was formerly a social scientist recalls one of her earliest research lessons; that correlation does not always mean causation; that statistics can only show us the present situation and cannot, by themselves, reveal the reason for that situation. Indeed, I loved her analogy. It was that a survey of shoe size and reading ability among Americans would reveal that the larger the shoe size, the higher the reading level. However, before those statistics mislead us, we must remember to take into account the factor of age, for infants have very small feet.
Then there is our own URJ President, Rabbi Rick Jacobs, who reminds us that when it comes to denominational breakdown, those Jews without religion are only second in number to Reform Judaism. That they claim no religion, yet affirm their Jewish identity, indicates that within that group there is a great untapped potential if we can only find the key to attract them to Reform Judaism, Reform Jewish beliefs, and Reform Jewish practices.
Then there is the writer who wrote a response to the article celebrating the imminent demise of Judaism. She points out that most Jews lack basic Jewish literacy. One cannot abandon what one never had in the first place. Therefore, the challenge before us is to transform what the first author considered to be “intrinsically meaningless” into something deeply meaningful. This, or course, is done through more effective Jewish education.
Of all the statements I read on the subject, the one I really resonated with the most was by an author who said: “I look forward to… well, to most things, because there really isn’t any other direction in which to look.” That is precisely what the synagogue world needs to do. We need to look forward to our future. We need to seriously examine these statistics, come to an understanding of where today’s American Jews are coming from in terms of their Jewish identity, and then do some serious reworking of synagogue life so as to draw them back to an attachment to our religion as well as our culture. No, we should not resign ourselves to becoming mere Jewish cultural institutions, for Jewish identity cannot long endure as a testimony to bagels and Seinfeld, as one author framed it. For it is our faith, when properly approached, which gives our Jewish identity, and particularly our Jewish values, their foundation. Without that faith, the rest is built on shifting sand. We cannot keep any synagogue building open for long if the primary purpose of our existence is merely to keep our buildings open. We must mean more than that to our members. We must mean more than that to all those Jews out there who consider themselves “spiritual but not religious.” We must become the spiritual home they are seeking. We must become a center of vibrant and meaningful Jewish life. The statistics of the Pew Study tell us where we are today so that we can better plan where we need to go if we are ever to see tomorrow.
 Schick, Marvin, “The Problem With the Pew Study”. Tablet Magazine
 Roth, Gabriel, “American Jews are Secular, Intermarried, and Assimilated. Great News!”, Slate Magazine.
 Blech, Rabbi Benjamin, “The Vanishing American Jew?”, Aish.com.
 Gurevitz, Rabbi Rachel, “The Pew Study: What the Stats Can and Can’t Teach Us”, Rabbis Without Borders.
 Jacobs, Rabbi Rick, “Don’t Give Up on Jews Who Care About Being Jewish”, HaAretz.
 Glick, Caroline, “Why Bother Being Jewish?”, the Jerusalem Post.
 Ibid, Gurevitz.
This entry was posted on November 14, 2013 at 12:45 am and is filed under American Jews, Attachment to Israel, Birthright, Conservative Judaism, Contemporary Jewish Identity Challenges, How Meaningful Religion is in One's Life, Intermarriage, Israel, Jewish, Jewish Ethnic Identity, Jewish Holidays, Jewish Identity, Jewish religious identity, Jews in American Society, National Jewish Population Study, Orthodox Judaism, Passover, Passover as most observed holiday, Pew Forum, Pew Study of American Jewish Community, Reform Jews, Reform Judaism, Religious Identity and Involvement Studies, Remembering the Holocaust as key aspect of Jewish identity, The Future, Uncategorized, Values. You can subscribe via RSS 2.0 feed to this post's comments.
Tags: American Jew, American Jewish, American Jewish community, American Jews, Attachment to Israel, Birthright, Conservative Judaism, Contemporary Jewish Identity Challenges, How Meaningful Religion is in One's Life, Intermarriage, Israel, Jewish, Jewish Americans, Jewish Ethnic Identity, Jewish Holidays, Jewish Identity, Jewish Religious Identity, Jews in American Society, National Jewish Population Survey, orthodox judaism, Passover, Passover as most observed holiday, Pew Forum, Pew Study, Pew Study of the American Jewish Community, Reform Jews, Reform Judaism, Religious Identity and Involvement Studies, Remembering the Holocaust as a key aspect aof Jewish identity, The Future, The Pew Research Center, ValuesYou can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.